The Ultimate Guide to Buttermilk Substitutes: Ratios, Science, and Recipes

by Anusha Danthanarayana
February 25, 2026
0
11 Min Read

The Ultimate Guide to Buttermilk Substitutes: Ratios, Science, and Recipes

There is nothing quite like the sinking feeling of having your flour measured, your oven preheated, and your butter softened, only to open the fridge and realize you are completely out of buttermilk. Whether you are throwing together a quick batch of scones before heading out to teach a full day of classes, or you are prepping a complex weekend layer cake, a missing ingredient can bring your kitchen to a grinding halt.

But do not abandon your baking project just yet. You do not need to make a frantic run to the grocery store.

Here at reciperange.com, we believe that understanding how ingredients work is the key to mastering the kitchen. In this comprehensive guide, we will give you the quick fixes you need right now, and then dive deep into the science of why these buttermilk substitutes work so perfectly.

The Quick Answer: 5 Easy Buttermilk Substitutes (1 Cup Ratio)

Need an answer right this second? You can easily make a 1-cup buttermilk substitute using ingredients you likely already have. Choose one of these five methods:

The Classic (Milk + Acid): 1 Tablespoon white vinegar or lemon juice + enough milk to measure 1 cup. Stir and let sit for 5 to 10 minutes.
The Cultured Swap (Yogurt): ¾ cup plain yogurt + ¼ cup milk.
The Rich Swap (Sour Cream): ¾ cup sour cream + ¼ cup milk.
The Dry Swap (Cream of Tartar): 1 ¾ teaspoons cream of tartar + 1 cup milk.
The Vegan Swap (Plant Milk): 1 Tablespoon apple cider vinegar + 1 cup soy or almond milk. Let sit for 5 minutes.

What Exactly is Buttermilk, Anyway?

To understand how to replace it, we first need to understand what it is.

Historically, buttermilk was the thin, slightly watery liquid left over after churning cultured cream into butter. It was naturally fermented by lactic acid-producing bacteria, which gave it a signature tangy flavor and a thicker consistency than regular milk.

Today, the “buttermilk” you buy in the carton at the grocery store is actually “cultured buttermilk.” It is made by taking regular pasteurized milk (usually low-fat or skim) and introducing specific bacterial cultures to ferment the milk sugars (lactose) into lactic acid.

This modern process guarantees a consistent acidity and thickness, which is exactly what modern baking recipes rely on.

The Science of Baking with Buttermilk

Why do recipes specifically call for buttermilk instead of regular milk? It all comes down to a simple chemistry lesson in your mixing bowl.

When you bake, you need a leavening agent to make your cakes, breads, and pancakes rise. The most common leavening agent is baking soda (sodium bicarbonate), which is a base. For baking soda to do its job, it requires an acid to react with.

When the lactic acid in buttermilk meets the sodium bicarbonate in your dry ingredients, they neutralize each other. This rapid chemical reaction produces carbon dioxide gas ($CO_2$). These gas bubbles get trapped in your batter, expanding as they heat up in the oven, creating a beautifully fluffy, airy lift.

Furthermore, the acid in buttermilk plays a secondary role: it tenderizes the gluten in your flour. By breaking down those long, tough protein strands, the acid ensures your final baked good has a soft, melt-in-your-mouth crumb rather than a chewy, bread-like texture.

By creating a substitute, our sole goal is to replicate that acidic environment.

Deep Dive: The Best Buttermilk Substitutes

Let’s break down exactly how to execute these substitutes and why they work.

1. Milk and Lemon Juice or White Vinegar

This is the holy grail of baking substitutions. It is fast, relies on absolute pantry staples, and perfectly mimics the acidity of cultured buttermilk.

The Ratio: 1 Tablespoon Acid + 1 Cup Milk.
The Method: Pour your tablespoon of freshly squeezed lemon juice or distilled white vinegar into a liquid measuring cup. Pour your milk (whole milk is best, but 2% works fine) up to the 1-cup line.
The Magic: Give it a gentle stir and walk away for 5 to 10 minutes. When you return, the milk will look slightly curdled and thickened. You have just rapidly soured your milk, creating the perfect environment to activate your baking soda.

2. Plain Yogurt and Milk

If you happen to have plain, unsweetened yogurt in the fridge, you are in luck. Yogurt is created through a very similar bacterial fermentation process as commercial buttermilk, meaning it already has the exact flavor profile and acidity required.

The Ratio: ¾ Cup Plain Yogurt + ¼ Cup Milk.
The Method: Yogurt is too thick to use on its own (it will throw off the moisture ratio of your batter). Whisk it thoroughly with the milk until it reaches the pourable, slightly heavy consistency of store-bought buttermilk.
Bonus Tip: Greek yogurt works too, but because it is so thick, you may need to adjust the ratio to ½ cup Greek yogurt and ½ cup milk.

3. Sour Cream and Milk

Sour cream is another cultured dairy product that provides fantastic acidity. Because sour cream has a higher fat content than standard buttermilk, using this substitute will often result in a richer, moister bake.

The Ratio: ¾ Cup Sour Cream + ¼ Cup Milk (or Water).
The Method: Whisk the two together until smooth. This is a phenomenal substitute for heavy, decadent recipes like chocolate cake, pound cake, or banana bread.

4. Cream of Tartar and Milk

Cream of tartar (potassium bitartrate) is a dry, powdered acid usually used to stabilize egg whites for meringues. If you want to add acidity without introducing liquid vinegar or lemon juice to your batter, this is the way to go.

The Ratio: 1 ¾ Teaspoons Cream of Tartar + 1 Cup Milk.
The Method: To prevent the cream of tartar from clumping up when it hits the wet milk, whisk the dry powder directly into your dry ingredients (flour, sugar, baking soda). Then, just add the 1 cup of regular milk when the recipe calls for the wet ingredients.

5. Kefir

Kefir is a fermented milk drink that is essentially a liquid yogurt. It is incredibly rich in probiotics and happens to be a perfect 1:1 substitute for buttermilk.

The Ratio: 1 Cup Kefir = 1 Cup Buttermilk.
The Method: No mixing required. Just measure and pour. Ensure it is plain, unsweetened kefir so you do not accidentally alter the sugar levels in your recipe.

Vegan and Dairy-Free Buttermilk Substitutes

Baking for a plant-based diet or a dairy allergy? You can absolutely still achieve that fluffy rise. The trick is choosing the right plant milk.

Soy Milk: This is the absolute best dairy-free option. Soy milk has a high protein content, which means it curdles beautifully when introduced to an acid, closely mimicking dairy milk.
Almond Milk: A great second choice, though the curdle won’t be quite as thick.
Oat Milk: Be cautious here. Oat milk is naturally lower in protein and often struggles to curdle properly, which can leave your batter a bit flat.

The Dairy-Free Method: Use the same ratio as the classic method. 1 Tablespoon of apple cider vinegar (or lemon juice) plus enough soy or almond milk to reach 1 cup. Let it sit for 5 to 10 minutes to curdle.

The Ultimate Substitute Matchmaker: What to Use When

Not every substitute is flawless for every single recipe. Here is a quick cheat sheet to help you choose the best option for what you are making today.

Recipe Type	Best Substitute	Why it Works Best
Pancakes & Waffles	Milk + Lemon/Vinegar	Provides the sharpest, quickest chemical reaction for maximum fluffiness.
Chocolate Cake	Sour Cream + Milk	The extra fat content in the sour cream makes the cake incredibly rich and fudgy.
Biscuits & Scones	Kefir or Milk + Vinegar	Biscuits require cold ingredients. Cultured dairy or soured milk provides tang without altering the fat structure.
Muffins	Yogurt + Milk	Adds a beautiful, tender crumb and keeps the muffins moist for days.
Cornbread	Milk + Vinegar	A thin batter needs a liquid substitute to maintain the proper hydration of the cornmeal.

Troubleshooting Your Bakes

If you use a substitute and your baked goods don’t turn out quite right, check these common pitfalls:

Your Milk Was Too Cold: If you are using the Milk + Vinegar trick, extremely cold milk takes longer to curdle. Let it sit closer to 10 or 15 minutes if it came straight from the back of the fridge.
You Overmixed: Because you are initiating a chemical reaction by adding acid to baking soda, you need to work quickly. Once your wet ingredients hit your dry ingredients, the reaction begins. If you overmix or let the batter sit on the counter for too long, those $CO_2$ bubbles will pop, and your cake will be flat.
Check Your Baking Soda: If you used a perfect buttermilk substitute and your pancakes still came out flat, your baking soda might be expired! Test it by dropping a spoonful into some vinegar—if it doesn’t immediately violently fizz, throw it away.

Can I just use regular milk without adding anything?

No. If a recipe specifically calls for buttermilk, it likely relies on baking soda for its rise. Regular milk is not acidic enough to activate baking soda. Your baked goods will turn out dense, flat, and may even have a soapy, metallic taste from the unreacted baking soda.

Does a buttermilk substitute taste like vinegar?

Not at all. The 1 tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice is entirely neutralized during the baking process as it reacts with the baking soda. You will not taste any harsh vinegar notes in your final dish.

How long does homemade buttermilk last?

The Milk + Vinegar/Lemon Juice substitute should be used immediately for your recipe. However, if you mix a batch of Yogurt + Milk or Sour Cream + Milk, you can store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

Can I freeze leftover buttermilk?

If you actually bought a carton and have some left over, yes! Pour the leftover buttermilk into an ice cube tray, freeze until solid, and then transfer the cubes to a freezer bag. Thaw them in the fridge overnight before your next baking project.

The Ultimate Guide to Buttermilk Substitutes: Ratios, Science, and Recipes

The Ultimate Guide to Buttermilk Substitutes: Ratios, Science, and Recipes